The Fortune Card debate ensues as expected. Like many others I am very surprised that Blizzard introduced them - its gambling and unfortunately there are some people who will get addicted. I fully expect Blizzard to withdraw them very quickly once the first compaints arise (which I have no doubt has already happened).
The profit side of these cards is all down to the percentage chance of winning v cost to make. We havent got that data (yet) but soon enough we will all know the tipping point and then we will all wait for the mat prices to drop (because it is unlikely the winning odds will change.
Meanwhile on Cael, several sellers are in /trade selling these items. 200g a pop at that!
Yes people are idiots.
Anyway, I happened upon one of the sellers (a friend) who was low on stock and he asked me to make 100 cards for him. His mats. 1000g tip.
So I did - it took 5 minutes.
The guy is very happy - he's going to sell them and clear 12k profit after the price of mats is taken into consideration.
Well I think he's happy. Well he was.
However, I might have put a ounce of doubt in his mind.
I asked him how long he thought it would take to sell the cards. "Two hours" he happily cried!
"So 12k for two hours work then?"
"Yes!" he replied.
"So 6k an hour then?"
"Exactly!"
"And you just paid me a thousand gold for 5 minutes work?"
"Yes thats all part of the costs. 7k on mats and 1k to you"
"Isnt that 12k an hour?"
I left it at that.
The profit side of these cards is all down to the percentage chance of winning v cost to make. We havent got that data (yet) but soon enough we will all know the tipping point and then we will all wait for the mat prices to drop (because it is unlikely the winning odds will change.
Meanwhile on Cael, several sellers are in /trade selling these items. 200g a pop at that!
Yes people are idiots.
Anyway, I happened upon one of the sellers (a friend) who was low on stock and he asked me to make 100 cards for him. His mats. 1000g tip.
So I did - it took 5 minutes.
The guy is very happy - he's going to sell them and clear 12k profit after the price of mats is taken into consideration.
Well I think he's happy. Well he was.
However, I might have put a ounce of doubt in his mind.
I asked him how long he thought it would take to sell the cards. "Two hours" he happily cried!
"So 12k for two hours work then?"
"Yes!" he replied.
"So 6k an hour then?"
"Exactly!"
"And you just paid me a thousand gold for 5 minutes work?"
"Yes thats all part of the costs. 7k on mats and 1k to you"
"Isnt that 12k an hour?"
I left it at that.

4 comments:
Hmm... I think your point is he'd be better off to have the profession himself and not have to tip, or that he's tipping too generously (or just that as awesome as he things he is, you just scored even better), but there's an implication here that it's better to be the tipped crafter than the tipping seller, and I just don't agree with that. I know you know this, but I don't want any reader to conclude that sitting back and crafting for tips for primary sellers is a better way to make money than being the primary seller.
You're only actually making double what he is for a 5 minute period. If you can do that same activity for the same tip solidly for 2 hours, you win by a long shot - but there's no chance of that.
Crafting for tips is a great way to make a quick buck here and there if the opportunity jumps at you while you're doing something else - having a slower but steadier income from your own selling activity will win every time. Moral of the story: keep your eye on trade while you do other good stuff, but despite sporadic awesome tips, it's not worth it to just troll for them!
This 12k an hour is a mistake I see so often made. It is *not* 12k an hour since you do *not* have the opportunity to do this for one consecutive hour. It is a one-time opportunity. It's the same as when I do not count all the time I put into my auctioneering and only record the time it takes me to open the mail next day. Look 5 minutes work, 34k in profits, that's over 400k per hour! Yeah right
These cards are, like all games of chance like them, a tax on the mathematically challenged. I don't blame the sellers who cash in on this.
However, the second these become profitable, scribes will either raise the price to other players, or shut the market down and use them all themselves (or both).
I'd expect Blizz to be keeping a close eye on this. That's probably a good thing for the gold-blogging community - though. The pioneers will likely make their gold before the hotfix, if there's any to be made.
This will drive volume in the Blackfallow Ink Herb market, which is something to watch.
Bit late on my response, but i would like to correct your figures. 15K profit, 4.8
K total on cost including what was paid to you.. :)
Post a Comment